Getting Your Class Action Waiver Past the California Supreme Court Remains Challenging
(for our Canadian readers, our featured treatise is Litigating Conspiracy: An Analysis of Co
mpetition Class Actions , Stephen G.A. Pitel, Ed.)
An excellent concise summary of Gentry v. Superior Court, where the California Supreme Court Questions Enforceability of Class Action Waiver on Public Policy Grounds is once again provided by the National Arbitration Forum, excerpt below.
By a 4-3 majority, the California Supreme Court reversed an order compelling arbitration and remanded the case to the trial court with instructions to use a multi-factor test in determining the enforceability of a class action waiver. The ultimate question for the trial court is whether class-wide proceedings would be “a significantly more effective practical means of vindicating the [statutory] rights” of the employees who belong to the putative class. Parties who prefer the simplicity of one-on-one arbitration should not be overly concerned by the majority holding because this decision has no application outside of the employment context.
For full text of NAF's summary, click here.
This pdf of the opinion comes to you courtesy of Jeffer Mangels Class Action Defense Blog with Jeffer's excellent case analysis from a defense perspective here.
Another good and thorough analysis appears here. Gentry v. Superior Court - California ruling on class action waiver in arbitration agreement.




No comments yet
Start the discussion by using the form below