About Us

Victoria Pynchon

As the co-founder of She Negotiates Consulting and Training, I offer my services as a keynote speaker, trainer and consultant....

She Mediates

ADR Services, Inc.

She Negotiates

She Negotiates

The 33 cent wage and income gap is unacceptable and unnecessary. So is the cliché glass ceiling. Bottom line, our...

Neutrality, NFL Referees, Federal Judges and Mediators

I'm just back from a Judicate West retreat where we discussed the legal, practical and ethical issues of "neutrality."  So it is with no small amount of interest that I read Concurring Opinions provocative post I Trust NFL Officials More than I Do Federal Judges (h/t Quizlaw).  

Here's what Erik Lillquist has to say about the NFL official/federal judge comparative neutrality quotient:

My motivation for the title of the post is that I think NFL officials are actually better than judges on a number of these scores. For instance, NFL officials do not have the repeat-player problem. Furthermore, NFL officials are graded on all their calls, from every game, ensuring that the same calls are being made in all situations (and these days, they have to contend with the possibility of instant replay review on every call). And unlike federal judges and (to a certain extent) major league umpires, NFL officials are subject to the real possibility of termination for poor performance, something that cannot happen to Article III judges and rarely happens with major league umpires. As this LA Times article notes, between 2004 and 2007, there was actually more new Supreme Court justices than new (full-time, I assume) major league baseball umpires. In the NFL, on the other hand, turnover is more common. Because being a NFL official is so relentlessly competitive, the result is that (I think) NFL officials are more likely to get the call right than your typical judge (or umpire). 

To say neutrality is not precisely defined in mediation theory and practice is a vast understatement.    Consider these definitions of neutrality as reported in a "Knowledge Base Essay" on Neutrality at Beyond Intractability.

According to experienced mediator Robert Benjamin, neutral mediators:

  • will not intervene in the substance of the dispute;
  • are indifferent to clients' welfare;
  • have no relationship with the parties outside of the mediation;
  • will not attempt to alter perceived power balance differences;
  • are disinterested in the outcome; and
  • are unconcerned with the impact of the settlement on unrepresented parties. 

In contrast, Kevin Gibson, Leigh Thompson, and Max Bazerman (1996) identify three distinct conceptions of neutrality.

  • Neutrality as impartiality, which holds that the mediator should be free of bias and should set aside his or her opinions, feelings, and agendas.
  • Neutrality as equidistance, which focuses on the idea that mediators should try to give equal consideration to each side.
  • Neutrality as a practice in discourse. Mediators are supposed to shape problems in ways that give all speakers a chance to tell their story in a way that does not contribute to their own de-legitimization or marginalization.
  • The mediator gives each side a chance to talk about their positions and concerns, and then reframes these issues in a more neutral way so that parties are more likely to listen to and understand the other side's viewpoint. 
  • Then the mediator helps the parties to explore settlement options and to move toward a solution that all can agree on. Neutrality means that the mediator who facilitates this discussion should not have an interest in advancing the goals and positions of any party involved.

Similarly, Rachel Field (2000) points out that the term 'neutrality' encompasses "issues such as

  • a lack of interest in the outcome of the dispute,
  • a lack of bias towards one of the parties,
  • a lack of prior knowledge of the dispute and/or the parties,
  • the absence of the mediator making a judgment about the parties and their dispute, and
  • the idea that the mediator will be fair and even-handed." 

Thoughts from our readers?

Comments (5)

Read through and enter the discussion by using the form at the end
short term loans - July 7, 2012 10:46 PM

Howdy, I believe your site could possibly be having internet
browser compatibility issues. When I take a look at your website in Safari, it looks fine
however when opening in IE, it has some overlapping issues.
I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!
Aside from that, fantastic site! Payday Loans

www.myquickcash.co.uk - October 13, 2012 1:09 PM

this image is without a doubt the enjoyable. my quick

mypaydayloansnocreditchecktoday.co.uk/ - February 5, 2013 10:20 PM

Once the state started borrowing from the bank
to buy qualities, debt had been a more conscionable problem and therefore even as rushed right into
a new one hundred year with sub-prime applying
for taking off, that it was also only a matter of occasion before cash advance loans
lost virtually any negative explanations payday loans no credit
check Whether you may have just been cleared from chapter 7 or experiencing
a bad credit score, an undesirable credit unsecured loan
might be the assistance you'll need

推薦 バレエ 専門店 - January 15, 2014 7:52 AM

I'm curious to find out what blog system you're working with?
I'm having some small security problems with my latest site and I would like to find something more safeguarded.

Do you have any recommendations?

推薦 バレエ 専門店 - January 15, 2014 7:52 AM

I'm curious to find out what blog system you're working with?
I'm having some small security problems with my latest site and I would like to find something more safeguarded.

Do you have any recommendations?

Post a comment

Fill out this form to add a comment to the discussion
I'd like to leave a comment. is
  • 4media dvd ripper standard 5
  • adobe audition cs5.5 mac
  • adobe creative suite 4 web premium mac
  • autodesk building design suite ultimate 2012
  • techsmith camtasia studio 7
  • adobe flash builder 4.7 premium
  • adobe photoshop cs5 mac
  • corel wordperfect office x4 standard
  • adobe creative suite 6 production premium student and teacher edition
  • visual studio 2010 premium
  • autodesk maya 2013
  • nuance pdf converter professional 5
  • adobe cs6 production premium student and teacher edition mac
  • autodesk autocad electrical 2011
  • autodesk autocad map 3d 2009
  • pitney bowes mapinfo professional 11.5
  • adobe cs6 design standard student and teacher edition mac
  • infinite skills - learning bootstrap 2 mac
  • daz bryce 5.5
  • thegrideon access password professional 2.0
  • adobe flash professional cs5.5
  • autodesk navisworks manage 2009
  • microangelo toolset 6
  • autodesk alias design 2012 mac
  • parallels desktop 9 mac
  • futuremark 3dmark 05 pro
  • filemaker pro 11 advanced
  • adobe dreamweaver cc mac
  • infinite skills - advanced html5 training
  • autodesk autocad 2011 mac
  • excel 2010 all-in-one for dummies
  • adobe photoshop cs3 photographers guide
  • quarkxpress 10
  • camtasia studio 8
  • apple mac os x 10.8 mountain lion